A clever burglar with a soft spot for flowers gets outsmarted by an even cleverer trickster — and his greatest weakness turns out to be that he trusted the wrong person.
✍ Author
Victor Canning, a popular British thriller and crime-fiction writer.
👤 Main character
Horace Danby — a 50-year-old respectable locksmith who is secretly a thief.
📍 Setting
Shotover Grange, a grand country house with a famous safe full of jewels.
🎭 Genre
A crime story with a twist ending — ironic, humorous and full of suspense.
Who is Horace Danby?
Horace Danby was about fifty years old and unmarried. To everyone who knew him, he was a good, honest citizen who made locks and employed two assistants. But this respectable appearance hid a secret: Horace Danby was also a successful burglar. He was not greedy. Once every year, he carefully robbed a safe, sold what he stole, and used the money to buy the rare and expensive books he loved. People who do not know him might think he was a typical criminal, but the author tells us plainly that “he was good and respectable — but not completely honest.” This gentle contradiction is the heart of the story’s humour and irony.
The plan: robbing Shotover Grange
That particular year, Horace planned to rob Shotover Grange. He had spent two weeks studying the house carefully. He watched the family and the servants, learned their daily habits, and discovered that the house would be empty in July when everyone went out for the day. He knew there was a safe hidden behind a painting in the drawing room, and he believed it held jewels worth fifteen thousand pounds. He had also prepared his tools and was confident, because he had read many detective stories and learned how thieves get caught. He even wore gloves so he would leave no fingerprints.
A weakness for flowers
Horace had one small weakness — he suffered badly from hay fever, an allergy that makes a person sneeze. On the day of the robbery, as he entered the house, he was met by the strong scent of fresh flowers. There were lovely flowers in almost every room. This sweet smell triggered his hay fever and he began to sneeze. This detail seems unimportant at first, but it becomes the key to the entire twist of the story.
The mysterious young lady appears
Just as Horace was getting ready to open the safe, a voice spoke from behind him: “What is it? What are you doing here?” He turned and saw an attractive young woman in a red dress. She seemed calm and even friendly. She told him that she was the lady of the house and that she had returned home unexpectedly. Horace was frightened of being handed over to the police, but the lady spoke gently. She said that since the house was insured, she did not really mind losing the jewels — but she wanted to wear them at a party that evening. She suggested a deal: if Horace opened the safe for her so she could take out the jewels for the party, she would not call the police. In return, he could take whatever else he liked.
How Horace was tricked
Believing he had found an easy way out, Horace agreed. Because his hands were sweating and he kept sneezing, he found it hard to work in gloves, so he took them off to open the safe more easily. He opened the safe, the lady took the jewels, thanked him sweetly, and let him leave. Horace went home feeling clever and lucky — he thought he had escaped without trouble. But two days later, the police arrested him for the robbery at Shotover Grange. His fingerprints were all over the room because he had removed his gloves.
The shocking truth
The real shock came when Horace insisted that the lady of the house had asked him to open the safe. The real Mrs Gilbert, the actual owner, had never seen him before. The charming young woman in the red dress was not the owner at all — she was another thief who had also come to rob the house that day. She had simply used Horace to open the safe for her, taken the jewels, and walked away free, leaving Horace to take the blame. Now Horace sits in prison, working in the prison library, and he gets angry whenever he thinks how a thief tricked another thief. He has even decided that, when he is free, he will give up housebreaking and keep his hands honest — or so he says.
Why “a question of trust”?
The sub-title points to the central lesson. Horace placed his trust in a complete stranger simply because she looked respectable and spoke kindly. He, a careful and experienced burglar, was fooled by appearances — the very thing he relied on to fool others. The story shows that trusting someone only because of how they look or sound can be a costly mistake. Ironically, a dishonest man is undone by misplaced trust, while the truly dishonest woman walks free.
- Horace plans his once-a-year robbery at Shotover Grange.
- The scent of fresh flowers triggers his hay fever and he sneezes.
- A young lady in a red dress “catches” him and offers a deal.
- He removes his gloves to open the safe — and leaves fingerprints.
- The lady takes the jewels and lets him go.
- Two days later the police arrest Horace for the theft.
- The truth: she was a thief too, who tricked him into doing the work.
“Horace Danby was a thief who was outwitted by his own habits and his misplaced trust.” Discuss with reference to the story.
- Open with the central idea: Horace was careful, yet his weaknesses defeated him.
- Show his habit of trusting appearances.
- Link his hay fever to the fatal mistake of removing his gloves.
- Explain the irony of a thief being robbed by a thief.
- Close with the moral about trust and appearances.
Remember the chain FLOWERS → SNEEZE → GLOVES OFF → FINGERPRINTS → ARREST. The flowers start it and the fingerprints finish it — while the red-dress lady is the “trust trap” in the middle.
Do not write that the lady was the owner of the house — she was a second thief who pretended to be the owner. Also remember Horace was caught because of fingerprints (he took off his gloves), not because the police saw him. Always name the author as Victor Canning and the house as Shotover Grange.
Q1. How did Horace Danby prepare for the robbery, and what was his fatal mistake?
Answer: Horace prepared very carefully. He spent two weeks studying Shotover Grange, learning the habits of the family and servants and discovering that the house would be empty in July. He knew about the safe hidden behind a painting and believed it held jewels worth fifteen thousand pounds. To avoid leaving any clue, he wore gloves so as not to leave fingerprints. His fatal mistake came from his hay fever: the smell of fresh flowers in the house made him sneeze, and with sweating, restless hands he removed his gloves to open the safe more easily. As a result he left his fingerprints all over the room, which led the police straight to him.
Q2. Who was the lady in the red dress, and how did she trick Horace?
Answer: The attractive young woman in the red dress pretended to be the lady of the house, Mrs Gilbert, but she was actually another thief who had come to rob the same house on the same day. She caught Horace at the safe and spoke to him calmly, saying that since the house was insured she did not mind losing the jewels but wanted to wear them at a party. She offered him a deal: if he opened the safe so she could take the jewels, she would not call the police, and he could keep anything else. Horace trusted her and opened the safe. She took the jewels, thanked him, let him go, and left him to be blamed for the robbery. Thus she cleverly used him to do the dangerous work while she escaped free.
Q3. Why is the story titled “A Question of Trust”? What is its central theme?
Answer: The story is titled “A Question of Trust” because Horace’s downfall is caused by his misplaced trust in a complete stranger. He believed the young woman simply because she looked respectable and spoke politely, never suspecting she was a thief. The central theme is that we should not judge people only by their appearance or manner, and that placing trust in the wrong person can lead to disaster. There is also deep irony: Horace himself fooled people by appearing respectable, yet he was fooled in exactly the same way. A dishonest man trusted another dishonest person and paid the price.
Q4. Describe the character of Horace Danby. Was he a typical criminal?
Answer: Horace Danby was about fifty, unmarried, and ran a lock-making business with two assistants. To others he seemed a good, honest, respectable citizen. He was not a typical criminal: he robbed only once a year, was not greedy, and spent his money on rare and expensive books that he loved. He was intelligent and careful, planning every robbery in detail and reading detective stories to learn how thieves get caught. However, he had two weaknesses — his hay fever and his tendency to trust appearances. The author describes him as “good and respectable but not completely honest,” which captures his mixed nature perfectly. He is more an unlucky, gentlemanly rogue than a hardened criminal, which is exactly what makes his defeat both funny and sad.
- ✅ Horace Danby is a respectable locksmith who is secretly a once-a-year burglar.
- ✅ He plans to rob Shotover Grange but his hay fever makes him sneeze and remove his gloves.
- ✅ A lady in a red dress tricks him into opening the safe and takes the jewels.
- ✅ She was a thief, not the owner; Horace is arrested because of his fingerprints.
- ✅ Theme: misplaced trust and judging by appearances can ruin you — even a clever thief.
Book a free demo class