Can a single painted leaf save a dying girl? In O. Henry’s tender story, an old failed painter gives his own life to paint his masterpiece — one last leaf on a wall — so that a young artist may find the will to live. A beautiful tale of hope, sacrifice and friendship.
Author
O. Henry (real name William Sydney Porter) — American master of the short story with surprise endings.
Genre
Emotional / sentimental short story with a famous twist ending.
Main characters
Sue and Johnsy (young artist friends) and Behrman (the old painter).
Setting
A cold, damp artists’ quarter in a city, during a deadly outbreak of pneumonia.
The two friends and the deadly illness
The story is about three painters. Sue and Johnsy (Joanna) are two young women artists who share a small studio apartment. They are close friends. During a bitterly cold and wet season, an illness called pneumonia spreads through the city like a cruel, invisible enemy. Many people fall ill, and one of the victims is poor Johnsy. She becomes so seriously ill that she is forced to lie in bed, weak and helpless. The doctor who treats her is honest but worried, because Johnsy’s condition is not improving the way it should.
The doctor’s warning — the real medicine is the will to live
The doctor speaks privately to Sue and tells her a hard truth. He says Johnsy has only one chance in ten of recovering, and even that one chance depends entirely on whether she wants to get well. Medicine alone, he explains, cannot cure a patient who has given up hope. Johnsy has fixed it in her mind that she is going to die, and a patient who has lost the desire to live is very difficult to save. The doctor tells Sue that she must give Johnsy a reason to live and look forward to the future — only then can the medicine work.
Johnsy and the falling leaves
Sue discovers the strange and frightening reason for Johnsy’s loss of hope. As Johnsy lies in bed, she keeps her eyes fixed on an old ivy creeper climbing the brick wall of the house opposite their window. The cold wind is tearing off its leaves one by one. Johnsy is counting the leaves backwards — “twelve… eleven… ten…” — and she has convinced herself of a sad fantasy: that when the last leaf falls, she too will die. She has linked her own life to the dying creeper. No matter how much Sue scolds and pleads with her, Johnsy refuses to give up this gloomy belief, and lies waiting silently for the final leaf to drop.
Sue meets old Behrman
Worried and helpless, Sue goes downstairs to the room of an old painter named Behrman, who lives in the same building. Behrman is over sixty years old, poor, and rather grumpy and fond of drinking. He has been a painter for forty years but has never achieved success. He has always boasted that one day he will paint a great masterpiece, but he has never even begun it. When Sue tearfully tells him about Johnsy’s strange fancy about the last leaf, Behrman is angry at first and calls it a foolish idea. Yet beneath his rough manner, he is deeply moved and full of concern for the sick girl. He comes up with Sue to look at Johnsy and at the ivy creeper outside the window.
The terrible night and the leaf that would not fall
That night, a fierce storm strikes the city — rain pours down and an icy wind blows hard against the wall. Sue and Johnsy fall asleep. In the morning, Johnsy, certain that the storm has destroyed the creeper, orders Sue to pull up the window blind so she can see. To their amazement, one last leaf still clings to the ivy vine. Despite the rain and the savage wind of the night, that single dark-green leaf with its yellow edges has not fallen. It hangs bravely on the wall, refusing to give up.
Johnsy’s recovery
The leaf survives a second night of bad weather too. When Johnsy sees that it is still there the next morning, something changes inside her. She realises that the leaf has fought on against all odds — and she feels ashamed of her own wish to die. The brave little leaf teaches her that it is a sin to want to die. Her will to live returns. She asks for some soup, then a mirror, and says she hopes one day to paint the Bay of Naples. Slowly, with returning hope, Johnsy recovers. The doctor declares that she is now out of danger and will get well.
The surprise ending — Behrman’s masterpiece
Then Sue reveals the heartbreaking truth that gives the story its famous twist. The very same morning that Johnsy began to recover, old Behrman died of pneumonia in the hospital. He had been ill for only two days. People had found him helpless in his room, his clothes and shoes soaking wet and icy cold, with a lit lantern, a ladder, and brushes with green and yellow paint scattered nearby. The mystery is solved: on that stormy night, when the real last leaf fell, Behrman had quietly climbed out in the freezing rain and painted a leaf on the wall — so perfect that it looked completely real. That painted leaf saved Johnsy’s life, but the cold he caught while painting it killed him. The leaf was Behrman’s long-promised masterpiece — created at the cost of his own life.
- Johnsy — young artist who falls ill with pneumonia and loses the will to live.
- Sue — Johnsy’s loyal, caring friend who nurses her and never gives up.
- Behrman — the old, unsuccessful painter who finally creates his masterpiece — and dies for it.
- Johnsy counts the falling ivy leaves and believes she will die when the last one drops.
- After a stormy night, one leaf remains — it is secretly painted by Behrman.
- Johnsy recovers; Behrman dies of pneumonia caught while painting the leaf.
“Behrman’s last leaf was truly his masterpiece.” Discuss this statement with reference to the story. (Long answer)
- Recall his dream: For forty years Behrman had been a failed painter who always boasted that one day he would paint a great masterpiece — but he never even started it.
- Set the scene: When he learnt that Johnsy had linked her life to a falling ivy leaf, the rough old man was secretly filled with love and concern for her.
- The brave act: On a freezing, stormy night, when the real last leaf fell, Behrman climbed a ladder and painted a leaf on the wall so lifelike that it fooled everyone — even the artist Johnsy.
- The cost: While painting in the icy rain, he caught severe pneumonia and died within two days. He gave his life so that Johnsy might live.
- Conclude: The painted leaf was a masterpiece not because of its artistic beauty alone, but because it was created with supreme love and sacrifice, and because it achieved a miracle — it saved a human life.
Remember the three painters with “S-J-B”: Sue (the carer), Johnsy (the patient), Behrman (the saviour). And the theme in three words: Leaf → Life → Sacrifice — one fake leaf gives one real life through one man’s sacrifice.
Don’t say a real leaf saved Johnsy — the last leaf was painted by Behrman. Also remember the irony: Johnsy lives but Behrman dies. Spell the names correctly — Johnsy (not Johnny) and Behrman — and note the disease is pneumonia.
Q1. What was Johnsy’s strange belief, and how did it affect her health?
Answer: Johnsy, ill with pneumonia, developed a strange and gloomy belief while lying in bed. She kept staring at an old ivy creeper on the wall opposite her window, whose leaves were being blown away one by one in the cold wind. She began counting the leaves backwards and convinced herself that she would die the moment the last leaf fell. This hopeless idea was extremely harmful to her health, because she lost all desire to live. The doctor had warned Sue that medicine could only help a patient who wished to recover. Since Johnsy had given up the will to live and was simply waiting for the last leaf to fall, her chances of survival became dangerously low.
Q2. How did the last leaf bring about a change in Johnsy?
Answer: After a night of fierce rain and savage wind, Johnsy was sure the storm would have torn down the final leaf and ended her life. But when the blind was raised, she saw that one last ivy leaf still clung bravely to the wall. It survived a second stormy night as well. Seeing the little leaf fight on so courageously against the harsh weather filled Johnsy with shame for her own wish to die. She realised that wanting to die was a kind of sin, and her will to live returned. She asked for soup and a mirror, spoke of painting the Bay of Naples one day, and gradually recovered. Thus the brave leaf restored her hope and saved her life.
Q3. Why is the ending of the story called a “surprise” ending?
Answer: The ending is a surprise because the reader, like Johnsy, believes the last leaf is a real leaf that miraculously survived the storms. Only at the very end does Sue reveal the truth: the leaf was actually painted on the wall by old Behrman. On the stormy night when the real last leaf fell, Behrman climbed a ladder in the freezing rain and painted a leaf so lifelike that no one could tell it was fake. While doing so he caught pneumonia and died within two days. This twist — that the leaf was a painting and that the man who saved Johnsy gave his own life — is unexpected and deeply moving, and is typical of O. Henry’s famous surprise endings.
Q4. What is the main theme or message of “The Last Leaf”?
Answer: The main theme of the story is the power of hope and the beauty of selfless sacrifice. It shows that the will to live is as important as any medicine: Johnsy almost died not from her illness alone, but from her loss of hope, and she recovered the moment hope returned. The story also celebrates love and friendship — Sue’s devoted nursing and Behrman’s ultimate sacrifice. Behrman, a rough and unsuccessful old man, gave his life to paint a leaf that would save a young girl he barely knew. Through this, O. Henry teaches that true greatness lies in kindness and self-sacrifice, and that one act of love can be the finest masterpiece of all.
- ✅ Written by O. Henry; the three painters are Sue, Johnsy and Behrman.
- ✅ Johnsy, ill with pneumonia, believes she will die when the last ivy leaf falls.
- ✅ The doctor warns that her recovery depends on her will to live.
- ✅ One leaf survives two storms — it is secretly painted by Behrman, restoring Johnsy’s hope.
- ✅ Johnsy recovers, but Behrman dies of pneumonia caught while painting his masterpiece.
- ✅ Theme: hope, love and selfless sacrifice.
Book a free demo class